By Carl Shank
•
November 20, 2026
CHURCH GUARDRAILS. Are they biblically right? Are they necessary? Are they helpful or detrimental? After forty plus years in ministry, both as a pastor and church consultant in three very different denominational settings, I have observed church “guardrails” in most every church gathering I have encountered. Many would call such “guardrails” merely guidelines for proper church order and health. What I have found and experienced, however, instead of merely suggested guides for church life and faith, these act like rigid guardrails for church involvement. They range from church dress to church worship to church service. “You can’t preach here with a mustache!” said one deacon in a very conservative independent Baptist church to me as a guest preacher. “You can’t take communion here because you are not a member of our local church.” “Serving communion to the congregation must be done by approved and stated elders of the church.” “We sing only pastor or board approved songs here in our worship services.” “Only elders, and male at that, can read Scripture here in a stated worship service.” “You cannot join in our commissioning of new pastors because you are not a member of our denominational ministerial family.” “Unless you hold to a 24/7 day view of creation you are not able to teach here.” “No dancing in our church!” “Your view of the end times must coincide with our viewpoint for membership here.” “We use only the approved King James Version of the Bible here.” These and a multitude of other “guardrails” have been constructed in a variety of churches that all proclaim Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior and the Bible as the written Word of God. They are sincerely and seriously held as entry points for church life and faith. While a number of these assemblies would say they are merely “guidelines,” they instead either allow or forbid people from real involvement in the life and faith of that church. They are church strictures that have withstood the test of time in many places. However, are they biblically right or called for? Are they really necessary for the life and faith of a church or denomination? Are they helpful or detrimental to people who wish to participate in the local church scene? This book investigates some of these “guardrails” and gives biblical advice to churches and denominations. I write out of pastoral and consultant experiences and identification with three very different denominational and church ties. I have served as a pastor in a Reformed Baptist church setting, an Orthodox Presbyterian church and presbytery leader, and a Brethren in Christ pastor, church health consultant and denominational leader. My ministerial story is varied, to be sure, but in every case and situation I have sought to be true to the Scriptures and the call of God on my life and ministry. Such wide and varied, and some would say “contradictory,” church experiences have given me keen insights and appraisals of church guardrails. Obviously, some guardrails are more serious than others. Women in church ministry would be a heated debated guardrail in many church circles. Proper church dress, on the other hand, would be less of an issue in many church gatherings in our day. This book does not purport to solve major complex theological issues like women in ministry, or eschatological viewpoints, or creation theology. There are a multitude of books and papers and online materials available for each of these subjects with a multitude of differing viewpoints and perspectives, all claiming to represent what the Bible “really” says and means about these topics. This book, instead, looks at selected secondary, and somewhat arguably less debated, church guardrails. By choosing these topics, my hope and prayer is to give biblically based, intentional ways to defuse church disruptions and advance overall church health and vitality, even in the major church guardrail debates today. Way too many churches have been split apart and sincere Christian people hurt by such guardrails. My overall guiding thesis is the prayer of Jesus — “Holy Father, keep them in your name, which you have given me, that they may be one, even as we are one.” (John 17:11), and Paul’s admonition — “I therefore, a prisoner for the Lord, urge you to walk in a manner worthy of the calling to which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, eager to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace.” (Ephesians 4:1–3) Debate is easy. Resolution is hard. Consideration is demanded. Cooperation can be attained. Table of Contents Why Guardrails? Judging Others: “No Dancing” The Regulative Principle: Worship Guardrails Bible Translations: KJV Onlyism Theological Guardrails: The Purity Guardrail Moral Guardrails: “No Alcohol” Moral Guardrails: “No Gambling” Technology Guardrails: The AI Challenge Addendum: Theological Guardrails Gnosticism & Christianity You can purchase a discounted copy at cshanktype@gmail.com